“ My friend Mel turned me on to this place years ago. I stop in every time I'm in the neighborhood. I have to be honest I did have one bad lunch ..a couple of slices that were extremely too greasy..99% of the time its perfect!! I love their pizza. It's one of the best to me!! The sauce is delicious because you can actually taste the flavor of the tomatoes. ”

“ ETA: consistently delicious!!! Family run very friendly and accommodating! We had the broccoli white, plain white, plain, Buffalo chicken pizza, garlic knots every time because they're amazing. Mozzarella triangles are a great addition to any order! Delicious and crunchy not soggy. I look forward to going through the menu, supporting local and having a great addition to the Elmer area! ETA: boneless tenders in the garlic parm sauce are another favorite ”

“ Amazing .Me and my brother get pizza from here all the time. I threw a mini party for my boss and coworkers with The works pizza... everyone was just asking me where I got it from. This place is straight money. Everytime I order from them they are always good. It's obvious they have great leadership and care about their quality. Go to spot for pizza, and their wings are pretty good too. Guess my only complaint is they don't deliver and aren't open everyday but that's a pretty small complaint. ”

“ We are overjoyed that Sal is back and has reclaimed Mannino's Pizza. Its better than ever! As a longtime fan of his food, we can't express enough how thrilled we are to see its revival. And let's talk about the ambiance. Walking into Mannino's Pizza Place feels like coming home. The cozy interior, with its warm lighting and welcoming decor, instantly puts you at ease. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice with friends or settling in for a family dinner, the atmosphere here is inviting. Now, onto the main event: the pizza. From the crispy crust to the perfect ratio of sauce to cheese, every bite is a slice of perfection. The menu offers a variety of toppings to suit every palate, from classic pepperoni to inventive combinations like the dill pickle (my personal favorite) that push the boundaries of flavor. But it's not just the food that makes Mannino's so special—it's the people behind it. Sal, Kasey and the rest of the staff are always friendly, attentive, and passionate about what they do. Whether you're a regular or a first-time visitor, you're treated like part of the family from the moment you walk through the door. Welcome back, Manninno's! Welcome back! The Carneys ”

“ Came in at 9pm, closing time. Didn't expect to get a pizza. Ovens were still hot enough to cook up one for us. I'm a truck driver and have had pizza in probably 30 of the states. I won't soon forget the service first of all and the fresh dough, cheese, pepperoni and sausage with the sauce, my God the sauce. He has a gem in the little town of Elmer. My children were hungry beyond belief and I'm grateful that he served us. When I'm close to town wanting good food, I'll not hesitate to stop in. Thanks for the pleasure. ”

“ This little place is a gem. New owners are determined to keep the quality and welcoming atmosphere of Frank, the original owner, and add a few new things, such as pizza cones and milkshakes. Chicken Caesar Salad is yummy!! ”

“ I can say how much I like the food the atmosphere and the service but Until you go for yourself, you’ll never Fully appreciate how great it is ”

“ Love their cheese steaks......loaded fries.....cold hoagies......and pizza. Very friendly. Great food....nice local pizzeria....you know it's good pizza when it doesn't fold down all soggy ... ”